I really liked the price of these shorts compared to other J.Crew Mercantile shorts. Couldn't pass up the opportunity to give them a try! They fit according to size and the color is vibrant - love it! The only thing keeping me from 5-stars is that come out of the wash a little wrinkled. I prefer shorts that I can wash and wear without ironing; however, these will require a quick iron touch-up before wearing. Wouldn't stop me from buying more though - I wish I could find more colors at this price!