Shorts are great and size is accurate. Liner is a little snug on legs, but at least it's removable.Several compliments so far ?I really wanted to like these bike shorts since I'm partial to shorter shorts, but I suspect it would only be adequate for short rides due to two factors:1) Padding is in an underwear style, so probably limited to 1 hour rides2) I took it out for a very quick test ride and the outer shorts immediately rode up past my inner thighs, leaving my inner thighs to rub uncomfortably against my saddle.Sadly returned. It would work well for short rides and for general running around in.The color is great, the fit is great. I'm happy with it. Pearl izumi did really well with the sizing for x-small. No gap and the band is flush. The waist is higher in the back so no peeking crack. I like the liner.Kinda wish there was a back pocket for a phone. I'm a commuter and I like having the phone in my pocket.These are great for mountain biking and keep my butt from getting saddle sore. My only complaint is that the liner shorts are too tight while the outer shorts are too big.Thsee shorts are comfortable, and I like the color. I wouldn't suggest them for cycling though. I feel they are way too short to be comfortable while riding. They also don't have pockets, and I feel like the snap button on the front kind of digs into my skin. I would wear these runbing perhaps, but not cycling, they tend to ride up too much.The shorts fit perfect to size chart , love them . Every now and then riding down hill they get slightly caught on the seat due to the length . But hey , I bought them because I love the shorter length .Great for short rides about town because chamois is very thin. Great running shorts with liner removed. I will use them for short rides and running.